Friday’s Insider: The EU’s growing dependence on Russian nitrogen fertilizers and the implications of new tariffs

The European Union has historically relied on Russian gas as a key input for its domestic nitrogen fertilizer production. However, over the past three years, its dependence has extended beyond raw materials to include the direct import of Russian nitrogen-based fertilizers.

EU import data underscores this increasing reliance:

• 2021: The EU imported approximately 2.33 million metric tonnes of nitrogen fertilizers from Russia.
• 2022: Imports increased to 2.56 million metric tonnes.
• 2023: A slight dip saw imports decline to 2.44 million metric tonnes.
• First half of 2024: The EU imported 2.56 million metric tonnes in just six months, matching the total volume for the entire year of 2022.

This trend suggests a significant shift in the EU fertilizer supply chain, raising concerns about strategic vulnerabilities and market concentration.

The European Commission’s response: New tariffs on Russian and Belarusian fertilizers

In light of these import trends, the European Commission has proposed new tariffs on nitrogen fertilizers and agricultural products from Russia and Belarus. If approved, these measures would add an additional 30% duty on top of the existing 6.5% import tariff, effectively making Russian fertilizers significantly more expensive for European buyers.

If these tariffs are imposed before the spring application season, the implications for supply, pricing, and global trade patterns could be profound. The key question remains: who stands to benefit from these restrictions?

Potential winners in a changing market

Reflecting on 2022, when the EU temporarily lifted its 6.5% import duty for all producers except Russia and Belarus, several new suppliers stepped in to meet demand. A similar scenario could unfold if the new tariffs take effect. The likely beneficiaries include:

• Nigeria: Geographically well-positioned to supply Europe and expanding its nitrogen production capacity, Nigeria could emerge as a significant alternative supplier.
• Egypt and Algeria: Both countries already have a strong presence in the European market and may strengthen their positions further.
• Arabian Gulf producers: Fertilizer producers from countries like Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and the UAE will likely seek to capture a larger share of the EU market.

Russia’s next moves: Diversifying export markets

Despite potential losses in the European market, Russia has been expanding its footprint elsewhere:

• Latin America: Russian fertilizers have gained traction in Mexico, Argentina, and Brazil.
• India: Russian producers have actively participated in government tenders, securing a foothold in one of the world’s largest fertilizer markets.
• Turkey and the US: Both markets have seen increased Russian supply in recent years.
• East Africa and Southeast Asia: These regions are expected to become the next strategic focus for Russian fertilizer exports as Moscow seeks to offset potential losses from the EU market.

Conclusion: a potential reshaping of global fertilizer trade

If the proposed EU tariffs are implemented, the European nitrogen fertilizer market could undergo a fundamental transformation. While alternative suppliers are poised to step in, Russian exporters will likely intensify their efforts to penetrate new markets, further shifting global fertilizer trade dynamics.

Ultimately, the effectiveness of these tariffs will depend on Europe’s ability to secure alternative supplies without significantly increasing fertilizer costs for farmers. As spring application season approaches, all eyes will be on Brussels’ next move and its impact on European agriculture and the global fertilizer trade.

————

About the Author of “Friday’s Insider”: Ilya Motorygin is the co-founder of GG-Trading and brings 30 years of experience to the fertilizer industry. Renowned for his comprehensive problem-solving skills, Ilya expertly manages deals from inception to completion, overseeing aspects such as financing, supply chains, and logistics.