Greenhouse nitrogen fertilization at 720.5 kg N/ha cuts zucchini yield 33%

Greenhouse nitrogen fertilization at excessive rates reduced zucchini fruit yield by about 33% in a South Korean trial, while increasing nitrogen losses to air and water. The high-input plots received 720.5 kilograms of nitrogen per hectare and produced 1,855 kg/ha of fruit, compared with 2,751 kg/ha under the low-input treatment.
The study examined nitrogen inputs, crop uptake, and environmental losses in three plastic greenhouses in Daegok-myeon, Jinju, Gyeongsangnam-do. The sites had grown zucchini continuously for more than five years. Researchers compared three nitrogen treatments during one growing season, from transplanting in late September through harvest in early July.
The results challenge the assumption that heavier fertilizer applications protect yields in intensive greenhouse production. High nitrogen input was associated with lower fruit output and poorer crop recovery of applied nitrogen, alongside larger atmospheric emissions and estimated leaching. Earlier research covered by Fertilizer Daily found that reduced tillage cut nitrous oxide emissions in organic grain, and that compost from human excreta could replace mineral fertilizer in a kohlrabi trial. The findings are reported in the Journal of Agriculture and Food Research.
High nitrogen input did not improve zucchini yield
The low, medium, and high treatments received 238.1, 337.9, and 720.5 kg of nitrogen per hectare, respectively. The fruit-yield figures were 2,751 kg/ha for the low treatment, 2,549 kg/ha for the medium treatment, and 1,855 kg/ha for the high treatment. The high-input yield was about 33% below the low-input result, calculated from the reported values.
Livestock compost supplied 672.8 kg N/ha in the high treatment, more than 3.3 times the 200 kg N/ha greenhouse-zucchini recommendation cited in the report. Across the treatments, inorganic fertilizer contributed 32.8 to 48.4 kg N/ha, with the balance coming from compost and commercial organic fertilizers. The trial therefore tested a large difference in total nitrogen loading, much of it from organic sources.
Crop nitrogen uptake was 189.5 kg/ha in the low treatment and 191.4 kg/ha in the medium treatment, then fell to 162.5 kg/ha under high input. The reported nitrogen absorption ratio dropped from 79.6% in the low treatment to 22.5% in the high treatment. In practical terms, adding more nitrogen did not translate into more nitrogen recovered by the crop or more zucchini fruit.
Higher rates increased nitrogen losses
Measured nitrous oxide emissions rose from 2.2 kg N/ha in the low treatment to 9.0 kg N/ha in the high treatment, about four times as much. Ammonia volatilization increased from 19.4 to 83.6 kg N/ha, also more than fourfold. The researchers estimated nitrogen leaching at 57.1 kg/ha under low input and 172.9 kg/ha under high input; this pathway was calculated with a default coefficient of 0.24 rather than measured directly.
The study’s apparent nitrogen balance, calculated as inputs minus quantified outputs, ranged from a 20.0 kg N/ha deficit in the low treatment to a 300.9 kg N/ha surplus in the high treatment. The surplus is an accounting balance, not a direct measurement of nitrogen stored in the soil. It indicates that a large share of the high treatment’s input was not accounted for in crop uptake or the loss pathways quantified by the study.
One season limits conclusions for other greenhouses
The trial covered nine plots at three greenhouses in one South Korean district and ran for a single growing season. Its results do not establish an optimal nitrogen rate for every soil, greenhouse, or zucchini production system. The researchers called for multi-year and multi-site work to assess longer-term soil effects and confirm how application rates affect yields and nitrogen losses.
For greenhouse operators, the findings support matching compost and fertilizer applications to crop requirements rather than using additional nitrogen as yield insurance. The study did not calculate fertilizer-cost savings or farm-level returns, so it cannot quantify the economic benefit of reducing rates. Its measured yield and loss differences point to a management trade-off that further trials can test under local production conditions.
Source: Bioengineer.org

Enjoyed this story?
Every Monday, our subscribers get their hands on a digest of the most trending agriculture news. You can join them too!









Discussion0 comments